Police Can't Stop Passengers In Traffic Stops, Court Rules
May 6, 1999
Palm Beach Post
Police officers cannot summarily stop passengers in cars from walking away if the car has been pulled over in a traffic stop, the 4th District Court of Appeal ruled Wednesday.
Police must have a reasonable suspicion that the passenger in the car is involved in criminal activity or poses a danger to officers, the court said.
Otherwise, ordering the person back to the car would be a violation of his or her right to be protected from unnecessary searches.
While the court said the driver could be held in the car based on the traffic infraction, "a wholly innocent passenger should have the right to choose whether to continue on with his business or return to the vehicle."
Michael Neimand of the state Attorney General's Office said his office will ask for a rehearing or appeal the decision to the Florida Supreme Court. The court did not strike the proper balance between personal liberty and an officer's concern for his safety, Neimand said.
"I think that's a significant misinterpretation of the law," he said.
The ruling was made in the case of Jeff Wilson, 21, of Royal Palm Beach, who was arrested on drug charges in July 1997 while riding in another person's car. A Palm Beach County sheriff's deputy stopped the car in the parking lot of a bar, but when Wilson got out and walked toward the bar, the deputy ordered him back.
The deputy, Sean Murray, said he made Wilson wait in the car for safety reasons - not because Wilson appeared dangerous, but because the bar had a rough reputation. The appeals court said that wasn't enough.
Wilson was charged with possession of cocaine, marijuana and drug paraphernalia after he was searched. But the court called the search improper, and the drugs found can't be used against him.
The court has found that police can order drivers and passengers to get out of a vehicle to ensure officers' safety.
And last month, the U.S. Supreme Court said police can search a passenger's purse or other possessions if officers suspect the car contains illegal drugs or guns.
Copyright 1999, The Palm Beach Post
In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107 and The Berne Convention on Literary and Artistic Works, Article 10, news clippings are made available without profit for research and educational purposes.